(BOLD = Still Playing or Completed Playing Career)
2022/2023:
Tyler Barth: Wilmington College
Drew Dickerson: Morehead State University
Ben Eha: Glenville State University
Kaden Gardner: Thomas More University
Luke Zimmerman: Thomas More University
2021/2022:
Jackson Belk: Thomas More University
Tayshaun Marshall: Thomas More University
Matt Mason: University of Cincinnati
Gabe Savage: Army (West Point Academy)
2020/2021:
Lex Briggs: Georgetown College
Matthias Cusick: Thomas More University
Graves Fryman: Thomas More University
Connor Lee: Centre College
Bradyn Lyons: Thomas More University
Wilson Pendleton: Georgetown College
Franklin Rogers: Charleston Southern University / Alcorn State University
Kyle Yarger: Centre College
2019/20:
Elijah Cusick: Thomas More University
Jonathan Coker: Kentucky Christian University
Kyle England: Wittenberg University
Leo Galan: Wittenberg University
Nikolaus Heckel: Thomas More University
Keegan Points: Mount Saint Joe's University
Mo Sissisko: Wittenberg University
2018/19:
Jacob Gideon: Western Michigan University
Mason Molique: Eastern Kentucky University / Kentucky State University
Jackson Saladin: Georgetown College
Jake Smith: U.S. Naval Academy Sprint Football
2017/18:
Parker Bisek: University of Toledo
Jacob Chisholm: University of Dayton
2016/17:
Collin Demetrakis: University of Louisville
Jackson High: University of Kentucky
Jake Long: Thomas More College
Tanner Morgan: University of Minnesota
Chase Ross: Eastern Kentucky University
Drew Turner: Lindsey Wilson College
2015/16:
Collin England: Union College
Jacob Hiles: Lindsey Wilson College / Thomas More College
Bryant Meihaus: Union College
Jaret Pogliano: Mount Saint Joseph / Eastern Kentucky University
Jake Rabe: Pikeville College
Tyler Selby: Georgetown College
Bailey Wallace: Mount Saint Joseph University
2014/15:
Grant Arwine: Georgetown College
John Belk Jr.: Campbellsville University
Gavin Brandt: Kentucky Christian University
Alex Brownell: Univesity of Kentucky
Brad Cleveland: Pikeville University
Logan Ross: Eastern Illinois University / Thomas More College
Ryan Woolf: Georgetown College
2013/14:
Lex Sowards: Indiana State University
Prior to 2013:
Conner Hempel: Harvard University
Vince Murray: U.S. Naval Academy
Tate Nichols: Notre Dame University
Andy Ridilla: Elmhurst College
Bill Schild: Centre College
Brad Weber: Butler University
Ryan Smith: Holy Cross University
Tanner Teepen: Morehead State University
Zac Lamore: Thomas More College
Adam Schmitz: Georgetown College
Jerrod Babik: Western Kentucky University
Zach Senvisky: Morehead State University
Mark Gray: Morehead State University
Scottie Gray: Marshall University
